'In trying not to sound the same as before, they've lost their identity'
'Reliance on big name vocalists risks Harris being categorised as 'just' a producer'
'There’s nothing much remarkable or ground-breaking here'
'A deep and rewarding experience'
'What should have been a heroic return wasn't quite that, but it did the job'
'The group sound fantastic and Guy Garvey has never been better'
And something else
The boring stuff