Track Reviews »
Gigwise RSS Feeds Bookmark and Share

Richard Ashcroft – ‘Why Not Nothing? /Sweet Brother Malcolm’ (Parlophone) Released 04/12/06

Richard Ashcroft – ‘Why Not Nothing? /Sweet Brother Malcolm’ (Parlophone) Released 04/12/06

Richard Ashcroft – ‘Why Not Nothing? /Sweet Brother Malcolm’ (Parlophone) Released 04/12/06 Add to My Fav Bands List
starno starno starno starno star
Share

The mysterious case of Richard Ashcroft’s disappearing talent would have left Sherlock Holmes himself scratching his head in bewilderment.  Almost a decade on from the magisterial ‘Urban Hymns’ and the inspiration, vision and, quite simply, tunes that made The Verve’s final opus such a thrilling listen seem as far from Ashcroft’s reach as ever. ‘Why Not Nothing?’ begins with a lumbering Motownish intro and then goes nowhere, brass honking gracelessly as the Wigan warbler huffs and puffs like a heavyweight gone to seed.  ‘Sweet Brother Malcolm’, although boring and mawkish, is slightly better in that it’s just about a fully realised song, although whoever told Ashcroft his Shane McGowan impersonation was worth committing to record  was badly mistaken.  Sometimes “rough” doesn’t equal “heartfelt”, just “crap”. 
(1)
  • What a shitty review.

    ~ by J 2/15/2008

    Reply to this comment


     characters left [+]  


    Register now and have your comments approved automatically!

    • MOTHERFUCKING YES!!! RT @Gigwise: Daft Punk 'To Play London and Manchester Shows In 2010': It's reported... http://bit.ly/CQsc8
      christog on Fri Nov 20 22:47:41 via TweetDeck
    • RT @Gigwise: Gibson Guitars Raided Over Alleged Use Of Rare Madagascan Timber: Their Tennessee HQ is stormed... http://tinyurl.com/y96zc2s
      SheyMcfez on Fri Nov 20 17:14:17 via Gravity
    • RT @Gigwise Gibson Guitars Raided Over Alleged Use Of Rare Madagascan Timber: Their TN HQ is stormed http://tinyurl.com/y96zc2s < Not good
      alternageekorg on Fri Nov 20 17:12:50 via web
    • RT - Think About Life Trigger Stage Invasion At M For Montreal: Day one comes to a hectic conclusion... http://bit.ly/1KiUr1 (via @Gigwise)
      JasonGregory on Fri Nov 20 17:09:50 via Tweetie
    • RT @Gigwise: The Beatles' Sir Paul McCartney And Ringo Starr Unite On New Album http://bit.ly/3CGV7o
      _barbarroja_ on Fri Nov 20 15:20:12 via TweetDeck
    Artist A-Z   # A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z