The instrumentals on Death are fine, but James simply can’t sing anymore. His crappy voice ruins the album and every Metallica live show that I have heard lately (like Bonnaroo 08).
Metallica can live on, but James needs to pack it up.
wtf are u smoking? I think his voice is one of the best parts of the album...different than his old style but a more growly type...he can’t sing" persay...the higher vocals of the 80s or early 90’’s as he has come out and said TBA damaged his vocal chords. But what Death Magnetic does great is slam your ass against a wall and holds you from breathing without letting up until the end of the final song...i effin love it. You have right to opinion tho, and
Congratulations to Jonathan for what is the most moronic comment I’ve ever come across. Idiot.
~ by James 9/4/2008
wow Jonathan im suprised, I agree live James doesnt have what it takes anymore but I thought the singing on the album was great. Pefect even.
~ by bob geldoff 9/4/2008
Jonathan, you moron you have not even heard the new album by what you say. Listen to the real leaks. You are crazy, this is the best album since 1988 and maybe better then Justice
- The instrumentals on Death are fine, but James simply can’t sing anymore. His crappy voice ruins the album and every Metallica live show that I have heard lately (like Bonnaroo 08).
Metallica can live on, but James needs to pack it up.
View 7 Replies
- wtf are u smoking? I think his voice is one of the best parts of the album...different than his old style but a more growly type...he can’t sing" persay...the higher vocals of the 80s or early 90’’s as he has come out and said TBA damaged his vocal chords. But what Death Magnetic does great is slam your ass against a wall and holds you from breathing without letting up until the end of the final song...i effin love it. You have right to opinion tho, and
View 2 Replies
- Congratulations to Jonathan for what is the most moronic comment I’ve ever come across. Idiot.

- wow Jonathan im suprised, I agree live James doesnt have what it takes anymore but I thought the singing on the album was great. Pefect even.

- Jonathan, you moron you have not even heard the new album by what you say. Listen to the real leaks. You are crazy, this is the best album since 1988 and maybe better then Justice
View 2 Replies
» View all 111 comments~ by Jonathan 9/4/2008
~ by Ken 9/4/2008
~ by James 9/4/2008
~ by bob geldoff 9/4/2008
~ by Mark 9/4/2008
Register now and have your comments approved automatically!