News »
Gigwise RSS Feeds Bookmark and Share

Magazine Apologises To The Black Crowes For Dishonest Review

They hadn't even listened to the record!...

Magazine Apologises To The Black Crowes For Dishonest Review

The American version of Maxim magazine has been forced to apologise to The Black Crowes after it awarded their latest album ‘Warpaint’ a rating without having even listened to the record.

The magazine gave the Crowes’ first record in seven years a 2.5 star rating, despite the fact that there were no promo copies of the album released, or, anywhere on the internet where they could have listened to it.

Writing on their website, The Black Crowes blasted the review, stating: "Incredulously, the magazine gave the album a two-and-a-half star rating, although neither the writer nor the editor could have heard more than one song - the single ‘Goodbye Daughters of the Revolution.’"

Their manager Pete Angelus took things a step further condemning Maxim’s actions as "a disgrace to the arts, journalism, critics, the publication itself and the public."

In response, Maxim have held their hands up and admitted to the blunder. Editorial director James Kaminsky said: It is Maxim's editorial policy to assign star ratings only to those albums that have been heard in their entirety.

Unfortunately, that policy was not followed in the March 2008 issue of our magazine and we apologise to our readers."

According to the BBC, it’s not yet clear whether the journalist who wrote the article will face any further action.

(8)
  • i give it 1 1/2 stars

    ~ by neil_hill_1 2/27/2008

    Reply to this comment

  • Who needs to hear the album? Surely a cursory listen of The Rolling Stones’ ’Exile On Main Street’ or anything by The Georgia Satellites will tell you all you need to know?

    ~ by Fred Zeppelin 2/27/2008

    Reply to this comment

  • It’s probably fucking dire anyway!!

    ~ by Black shites 2/27/2008

    Reply to this comment

  • Who reads the music reviews in Maxim anyway?

    ~ by charlie wahlie 2/27/2008

    Reply to this comment

  • why always end sentences with anyway anyway?

    ~ by go_truck_yourself 2/27/2008

    Reply to this comment

» View all 8 comments

 characters left [+]  


Register now and have your comments approved automatically!

  • RT @Gigwise: Morrissey Walks Out Of Liverpool Gig After Being Hit By Drink http://bit.ly/4xiqLj //Mozza,fica em casa,pq tá brabo!
    victorrib on Sun Nov 08 13:15:12 via TweetDeck
  • #FollowFriday @gigwise @worldofblues @FridayMixtape @MeLikeGoodMusic @themusicslut @MyStage_Music @FridayBruceFix @rftmusic @musicsinmyveins
    zandria1 on Fri Nov 06 15:23:26 via web
  • RT @Gigwise Eminem 'To Star In 3D Hip-Hop Horror Movie': http://tinyurl.com/yerm5js < File under Terrible Ideass for $200 Alex?
    alternageekorg on Fri Nov 06 15:14:40 via web
  • @Gigwise So exciting! Can't wait for the London gig. Muse Rocks!
    solamore on Fri Nov 06 15:13:08 via web
  • RT @Gigwise: Pet Shot Boys To Release Christmas EP: Ahead of festive UK tour... http://tinyurl.com/ydhpdno
    _barbarroja_ on Fri Nov 06 14:40:20 via TweetDeck
Artist A-Z   # A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z